Science Online | Books & Reports | Newsletters | SB&F | Annual Report | Store
Home About AAAS Programs Membership Publications News Career Resources
Search
Publications

Science Books & Films

Triple-A S: Advancing Science, Serving Society

Publications of AAAS and Science


sbflogo Sign In | Create Account Advanced SB&F Search
Go Search

 

 Current Issue 

Print Article
 

 Print Current Issue: January 2012, Vol. 48 Iss. 1

January Issue Highlights

Our January issue features our annual Best Books and Best Films list. Subscribers click here to see the lists..

Click here to see a  list of books and AV materials reviewed in this issue of SB&F. In order to view full text reveiws you must be a subscriber (subscribers download the current issue HERE to view these reviews). To learn more about subscribing visit our subscriptionpage.

Featured Reviews

This issue featured reviews of several highly regarded resources on evolution. See below.

 No Dinosaurs in Heaven.  New Day Films, 190 Route 17M Suite D , Harriman, NY 10926; 2010. Color. 53 min. DVD: $289.00 (Institutions, Colleges and Universities), $59.00 (K-12 Schools), $49.00 (Public Libraries).

YA, C, T, GA  ++ 

No Dinosaurs in Heaven chronicles the many significant issues and arguments necessary to understand and, in essence, to support the scientific basis for evolution. The film propels the viewer to the heart of the problem presented by the challenges of creationism to the teaching of a scientific approach. "No Dinosaurs in Heaven" emphasizes the point that science uses observations and actual physical evidence to establish facts and the basis for evolution. While on the other hand, creationism first states a view and/or conclusion, and then chooses and combines selective facts with religious beliefs, which are not necessarily scientifically sound. The science instructors in the film clearly stress the need for a critical analysis of all the facts and not just those that are selected to support a particular conclusion. No Dinosaurs in Heaven includes viewpoints of both science instructors and one instructor who is a staunch supporter of creationism. These individuals are interviewed in several locations including classrooms and other types of school environments. One cannot help but wonder from these segments why the creationism instructor is teaching evolution while not keeping an open mind as to its existence. The film points out the basis of the controversy and stresses that creationism does not address the observations and explanations of the evidence associated with establishing the scientific basis for evolution with any concrete arguments or facts. This point becomes quite evident from the statements of the creationist instructor, who quickly switches to other topics when he can't find any facts to refute the physical and empirical evidence presented to him. The viewer might wonder why this individual is teaching science. This is especially the case when students question him about his particular viewpoints. The situation raises the question as to whether an individual with a creationism point-of-view can truly present the scientific evidence for the existence of evolution in an unbiased manner. There are a number of interesting discussions, classroom sessions, and interviews, some with surprising results. With the awesome scenery of the Grand Canyon as a classroom, the viewer will be impressed with the conflict between creationism and the endeavor to prevent the religious attacks on the scientific basis for evolution. The subject of some films is meant to be tasted, while with other films such as No Dinosaurs in Heaven the subject matter should be chewed and digested.--George Allen Wistreich, East Los Angeles College, 

 

  Pringle, Laurence, with a forward by Jerry A. Coyne.  Billions of Years, Amazing Changes: The Story of Evolution. (Illus. by Steven Jenkins.)  Honesdale, PA:  Boyds Mills Press,  2011. 102pp. $17.95. 2011920604. ISBN 9781590787236. Glossary; Index; C.I.P.

EI-JH  ++ 

 

 This is a book about evolution for young people around the age of twelve, plus are minus a couple of years. As Professor Jerry A. Coyne (Ecology and Evolution, University of Chicago) points out in the foreword, while there are plenty of books on dinosaurs and fossils of all sorts (including the ancestors of humans), as well as a plethora of volumes on geology, zoology, botany, and general biology, for this age range, until now there has been a marked paucity of books for middle school readers specifically addressing evolution. This gap is all the more troublesome as it is during these crucial formative years that children should, in my opinion, be exposed to a clear understanding of just what biological evolution means and the diverse and overwhelming evidence that supports evolution via natural selection. In America today we are faced with a situation where a large proportion of the adult public doubts, or downright dismisses, biological evolution. Laurence Pringle’s new book may help to address this problem as the next generation matures. I have to admit that I was at first skeptical that the topic of evolution in all of its multiple facets could be dealt with sufficiently rigorously and also sufficiently comprehensively in a “book for children” (young teenagers are still children), but the author has succeeded admirably! Pringle has managed to address the major topics bearing on evolution in a relatively short, well-written, beautifully illustrated (glossy full-color photographs and diagrams throughout) book: paleontology, historical geology, rock dating techniques, Darwin and Wallace, genetics, “missing links”, island biogeography, plate tectonics, variation, competition, natural selection, coevolution, the concept of a species, and speciation (this is only a sampling of the topics covered). The text is up to date and authoritative throughout; it is a pleasure to read such a book and not find mistakes, even if only minor. The back matter includes an index, sources, and suggested resources for further information, as well as an extremely useful glossary. I believe our nation would be served well if every twelve-year-old had access to a copy of this book. I can envision making it required reading in all schools.--Robert M. Schoch, Boston University,  Boston, MA

 

 

Archived SB&F Issues

Back issues of SB&F are available for subscribers in PDF format. Select the publication year to display information on that year's SB&F issues:

2011 | 2010  |  2009  |  2008  |  2007  |  2006  |  2005  |  20042003  |  2002  |  2001

View entire archive